Ethan Graham has been searching for five years for the woman he once had a one-night stand with. His quest leads him to Kelly Jay and her pair of adorable twins. He suspects that he is actually the children's father. Ethan inserts himself into their lives, and develops a combative yet fond relationship with Kelly. However, a paternity test delivers a shocking result: he is not the biological father of the twins. Kelly comforts him. Just as hope seems lost, his secretary's guilty behavior suggests that the wrong report might have been taken...